What a Fundraising Consultant Can Do for Your Nonprofit (And 4 Things They Usually Don’t)
Is your nonprofit poised for growth but feeling a bit stuck? Are you ready to expand or grow your fundraising efforts but unsure where to begin?
Bringing in a consultant from a trusted fundraising consulting firm could be the transformational step your organization needs.
But it’s difficult to find the right one, especially if you’re a small to midsize nonprofit. Because consultants with big-organization playbooks may not offer advice that scales down well for smaller teams.
Whether you work in education, animal welfare, healthcare, or another part of the nonprofit sector, the right expert can help you develop your fundraising goals and a sustainable plan for growth.
Let’s dig in.
Free expert-created Nonprofit Growth Kit
Sign up to receive your fundraising growth toolkit—complete with donation page optimization checklists, impact story templates, and ready-made slides.
✋ Important note:There are no affiliate links for fundraising consultants or agencies in this article. 4aGoodCause is a donor CRM and fundraising software platform that is committed to supporting small to midsize nonprofit organizations, backed by 25+ years of nonprofit industry experience. While we do share how 4aGoodCause can help make your fundraising efforts easier and more sustainable, this article is meant to guide you through making the right decisions for your organization.
How a fundraising consultant can help if your organization is stuck
Sometimes, even the most dedicated teams hit a plateau. A fresh perspective and strategic guidance can make all the difference. This is where an outside fundraising consultant shines.
A consultant can assist by:
Introducing new fundraising solutions
Guiding your team through effective prospect research, and
Helping design fundraising campaigns that attract major donors and increase long-term giving.
Plus, the nonprofit industry is changing.
The truth is that grants are harder to come by, budgets are tight with changes in the economic and political climate, and your donors expect giving to be seamless and secure.
Finding the right consultant who’s on top of giving and fundraising trends can help you navigate these big changes—and can ensure your mission’s long-term fundraising success over time.
💡Bonus tip:If you’ve heard the buzz about monthly giving programs or DAFpay across our industry, find a consultant who deeply understands how and why these types of programs matter today.
“
As a professional web designer I had struggled to find a good all around donation software for my clients. 4aGoodCause not only looks much prettier than other donation pages, it incorporates more features than I've ever seen in one program.
Jeff Miller
President, Pueblo Web Design
What a fundraising consultant does
A professional fundraising consultant supports every stage of the fundraising process—from planning to campaign management—to ensure more successful campaigns and stronger donor relationships.
They act as a strategic partner (usually on a contract basis), offering an objective viewpoint to enhance your organization’s fundraising capacity.
Nonprofit fundraising consultants can:
Assess your current fundraising strategies: Identifying strengths, weaknesses, and untapped opportunities.
Develop comprehensive fundraising plans: Crafting tailored strategies for major gifts, grants, campaigns, and donor engagement.
Provide training and coaching to your team: Empowering your staff and board with best practices.
Conduct feasibility studies: Gauging donor interest and capacity for capital campaigns.
Streamline internal processes: Optimizing operations for greater efficiency and impact.
Offer interim leadership: Bridging gaps during staff transitions or major initiatives.
💡Did you know?With other donor CRM and fundraising software, leaving can mean starting your monthly giving program over. With 4aGoodCause, it’s as simple as taking your donors (and their info) securely with you.
“
Probably within a month [with 4aGoodCause], we had done four times what we were getting before.
Dave Andrews
KJOL General Manager
What a fundraising consultant does NOT do
It’s important to understand the boundaries.
A consultant is a guide, not a magician.
Nonprofit fundraising consultants typically do not:
Raise the money for you: While they provide the strategy and tools, your team is responsible for the direct solicitation and cultivation.
Serve as a long-term, permanent staff member: Their role is project-based, designed to build capacity and transfer knowledge.
Make decisions without your input: They offer recommendations and guidance, but the ultimate decisions rest with your leadership.
Guarantee specific financial outcomes: Fundraising involves many variables, and while they aim for success, direct guarantees are unrealistic.
How to set up your fundraising strategies for sustainable growth
Finding the right fundraising consultant shouldn’t be about getting short-term help alone; it’s also about investing in long-term problem-solving that empowers your team and strengthens your mission.
Ready to raise more and stress less?
At 4aGoodCause (4aGC), we believe small to midsize nonprofits deserve expert support tailored to their unique needs along with simple, powerful tools that make fundraising easier and more effective.
“
The customer service is just unreal.
Javier Silva,
Executive Director of Lacrosse the Nations
With 4aGC’s tools, you get:
A seamless donor CRM and fundraising platform that powers all the ways you donors prefer to give
The built-in Monthly Giving Toolkit—everything needed to start, run, and grow your recurring monthly giving program
Unlimited branded fundraising and donation pages that are easy to design and secure (no tech skills required!)
Whether you’re reworking and launching new campaigns, refining your fundraising strategy, or simply need a fresh perspective, 4aGoodCause can help you bridge strategy and technology to meet your long-term goals.
Fundraising software that feels like part of your team.
A: Fees vary depending on project scope, consultant experience, and your organization’s size. Most charge $100–$300 per hour or $5,000–$50,000+ per project.
Some work on a flat fee or retainer. While the investment can feel significant, it often pays off through improved fundraising systems, stronger donor retention, and long-term growth.
🏆 Success story: Learn how this small, independent radio station experienced ~5X growth shortly after switching to 4aGoodCause. Within a short time, their monthly giving had increased over 438%!
Q: Are fundraising consultants worth it?
A: Yes—when aligned with your goals, a consultant can be invaluable. They bring fresh perspective, specialized expertise, and help your team avoid costly missteps.
The result is stronger strategy, more efficient operations, and higher fundraising results. (Hooray!)
⭐️ What if there’s an easier way to maximize donations?There is. It’s called recurring monthly giving, and it generates 2.4X more revenue on average than one-time gifts. And our Monthly Giving Toolkit simplifies the whole program.
Q: How can a nonprofit fundraising consultant help your cause?
A: Consultants help nonprofits clarify goals, streamline fundraising, and engage donors more effectively. They can develop strategies, create systems or select the right tools, train your team, and design campaigns that deliver results.
At 4aGoodCause, you get digital tools that power your fundraising strategy and make online giving easy and donor-centered.
“
Working with 4aGC has been great! I would highly recommend. Our online monthly donations have gone up 300% since we started working with them. They listen to feedback and ideas and even implement them. Tech support has been breezy and prompt. It's the personal touch that sets them apart from the rest.
David Andrews
KJOL
Q: Can a fundraising consultant help your nonprofit organization build sustainable fundraising programs and campaigns?
A: Absolutely. A good consultant doesn’t just help raise money once—they help you build long-term systems for donor engagement and retention.
⭐️ Ready to make fundraising easier?Imagine stress-free fundraising with reliable monthly gifts. 4aGoodCause makes it simple to get started with our Monthly Giving Toolkit.
Ronald Pruitt
Ronald is the President and Founder of 4aGoodCause, the fundraising CRM that makes recurring, monthly giving a breeze for small nonprofits.
For over 25 years, Ronald has had the joy of doing what he loves, building online solutions that make a difference in the world. He’s helped raise millions of dollars online for small nonprofits across the country. Connect with Ronald on LinkedIn.
Grow your monthly giving program with our resources
