If you’ve ever wished for a way to give your nonprofit fundraising a little boost—without doubling your workload—let me introduce you to one of my favorite tools… the donation matching challenge.
They can really move the needle on reaching your fundraising goals:
Mentioning matching gift programs in fundraising appeals can increase responses by 71% and theaverage donation amount by 51%, according to our friends at Double the Donation.
Running your own matching gift challenge can help save your organization additional processing fees and ensure you’ll collect the contact information needed to reach out in the future.
That’s the kind of lift that gets board members, individual donors, and even corporate partners excited to chip in.
At 4aGoodCause, our small and mid-size nonprofit clients run successful matching donation challenges that spark donor engagement and bring in additional funds.
Whether you’re teaming up with a matching donor, partnering with a business as part of their corporate social responsibility (CSR) efforts, or simply encouraging your community to double their impact—this strategy works.
And today, I’m going to walk you through a few real-life examples and discuss why they’re successful. Sign up for the 4aGC newsletter to make sure you don’t miss out on examples like this in the future.
Over the years, I’ve seen a lot of great donation matching challenges. Big ones, small ones, anonymous donors, named donors—you name it.
I often think of a well-run matching challenge is like caffeine for your fundraising efforts. And who doesn’t like a little boost?
Below are 3 real-world examples of donation matching challenges from reputable organizations, both small and large.
If you’re thinking about running your own matching challenge, and I hope you are, these ideas should give you a little extra spark.
(Maybe your next campaign will be featured here one day!)
💡 Ready to double your donors’ impact?4aGoodCause makes it easy to launch matching gift challenges that raise more—and everyone gets unlimited campaigns. Take a look.
Opacum Land Trust: Year-end matching challenge
In their year-end donation matching challenge, Opacum Land Trust announced that an anonymous major donor pledged to match all donations made before December 31, up to $10,000.
The fundraising strategy was designed to inspire supporters to give before the year’s end, knowing that their contributions would go twice as far to protect critical lands in Massachusetts.
Opacum Land Trust: Year-end matching challenge
Why it works:
Urgency + deadline: The campaign ties the match to a clear year-end deadline—December 31—creating a sense of urgency with a limited time frame during the busiest giving season.
Double the impact messaging: By emphasizing that “every donation will be doubled,” the campaign makes the donor’s gift feel exponentially more powerful.
Community + conservation focus: Opacum connects the campaign directly to its mission of land conservation, helping donors see exactly how their support protects local natural spaces.
Anonymous donor appeal: The mention of an anonymous donor adds a bit of mystery, which can pique curiosity and inspire a “join the club” mindset—“Someone else believes in this work, and I can be part of it, too.”
Achievable goal: The $10,000 match cap is a motivating yet attainable goal for a small, community-focused organization. It shows donors that every contribution—large or small—matters.
Great job, Opacum Land Trust team!
Join the 4aGoodCause community!
Access real-life fundraising examples, matching gift strategies, and expert advice.
Greater Chicago Food Depository: Matching gift challenge
The Greater Chicago Food Depository ran a matching gift challenge where every donation made by March 31 was doubled, thanks to a generous matching gift opportunity from an unnamed donor.
The campaign highlights that every dollar donated during this period will have twice the impact, helping provide more meals to individuals and families facing hunger across Cook County.
Greater Chicago Food Depository: Matching gift challenge
Why it works:
Clear and immediate impact: The campaign uses powerful language like “your gift will be doubled” and emphasizes the real-life impact of donations—providing twice as many meals to neighbors in need. This makes the benefit tangible and urgent.
Time-sensitive deadline: The challenge is time-bound, ending March 31, which adds urgency and encourages donors to act quickly rather than putting it off.
Matching gifts = motivation: People are often more inspired to give when they know their donation will go further. A matching challenge incentivizes both first-time donors and existing supporters to make a gift now.
Community-focused: Hunger is an immediate, local issue. The campaign tugs at heartstrings by centering the message on helping neighbors in need—keeping the mission personal and relatable.
Trusted brand: The Greater Chicago Food Depository is a well-established nonprofit with a reputation for impact, giving donors confidence that their contributions are being put to good use—and doubled!
❤️ Find these examples helpful?That’s great! Sign up for the 4aGC newsletter to make sure you don’t miss out on inspiration for your next fundraiser.
National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA): Matching gift challenge
The National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA) is running a Matching Gift Challenge, where all donations made will be matched dollar-for-dollar, up to a total of $50,000. The campaign highlights the urgency of protecting America’s national parks, especially in the face of increasing threats from climate change, pollution, and overdevelopment.
National Parks Conservation Association (NPCA): Matching gift challenge
Why it works:
High matching cap shows big impact: A $50,000 match makes a powerful statement about the scale and urgency of their work. It signals to donors that their contribution is part of something really significant—and there’s a large-scale partner (or group of donors) backing it.
Urgent conservation mission: The campaign ties directly to pressing issues facing national parks today, such as political uncertainty and environmental degradation. The language emphasizes “protecting America’s most iconic places,” which sparks both emotional and patriotic motivations to give.
Dollar-for-dollar match: Simple math is powerful here. Donors immediately understand that the donation challenge takes their $50 and turns it instantly into $100, which makes the impact of their contribution feel much greater—without any extra effort on their part.
Limited-time opportunity (implied urgency): While the page doesn’t state a specific deadline, the phrase “right now, your gift will be matched” on the donation page adds an element of immediacy, encouraging donors not to delay.
Engaging and familiar brand: NPCA is a trusted voice in national park advocacy, and the campaign appeals to both long-time supporters and newcomers who care about preserving public lands.
💡 Did you know?4aGoodCause makes online fundraising events simple with easy-to-use features. Plus, its intuitive donor management and recurring giving tools help turn one-time attendees into lifelong supporters. See it for yourself.
Matching challenge campaign strategies are great to set up prior to giving days such as Giving Tuesday, SpringForward/Give to the Max, and these real-life examples of donation matching campaigns above will spark inspiration for your own initiatives.
If you’re new to matching gift campaigns, like a donation match challenge, a good place to start is by checking for local giving days in your area and syncing up your matching challenge campaigns to those days for the best bang for your donors’ bucks.
Sure, donors can give at any time throughout the year, but when you plan a specific challenge campaign, it brings more exclusivity to the event and creates a sense of urgency to give.
This can be huge for a bump in donation success.
Matching challenges are also great because:
Your donors know exactly what to do and when to do it by.
Your donors know that if the gift isn’t received by a certain date there could be negative consequences for the project, person or program you‘re trying to fund.
Your donors feel the “now or never” mindset which can urge them to give.
Your donors feel like they are part of an exclusive opportunity (or that the opportunity will expire quickly)—they don’t want FOMO (fear of missing out).
Working with 4aGC has been great! I would highly recommend. Our online monthly donations have gone up 300% since we started working with them.
David Andrews
Station Manager at KJOL
Top benefits of hosting a matching challenge campaign
When you host your own matching challenge fundraiser, you can keep more of what you raise—rather than going through a corporate partner or a larger, broader state-based matching campaign.
Why?
Because your online fundraising is linked to your own payment processor with rates you’ve negotiated… rates that are likely lower than if you were to pay a third-party processor plus national or statewide giving day campaign fees.
Additionally, when you host campaigns outside of your organization—for example, through a corporate sponsor that is matching donations to multiple organizations—it’s hard to say what type of donor information you will have full access to.
You may get the donations, sure, but will you get their:
Mailing address
Name
Email
Company information
By hosting a donation matching campaign on your own site, you can oversee the mandatory donor data that is collected with each online donation.
4 can’t-miss best practices for your donation matching challenge
I’m going to go over a few top best practices you need to keep in mind specifically for matching challenges—ones you also saw in the real-life examples above.
How to Create an Effective Matching Gift Campaign That Motivates Donors
Have the right fundraising platform in place
Make giving easy.
Your donation form should be simple, mobile-friendly, and ready to process those matching gifts without a hitch.
And if you can automate those match notifications or thank-yous? Even better!
💡 Double your impact without doubling your workload. 4aGoodCause makes matching campaigns easy to run and easy for donors to join. Learn more.
“
Our campaign for a new community concert piano has gone so much better than imagined thanks to the resources available to us as a 4aGC subscriber. Ronald and his team are VERY responsive when it comes to tech support questions and have been great fundraising consultants to us at each stage of our campaign. The subscription has more than paid for itself and I will be recommending 4aGC to all my colleagues in the not-for-profit sector.
Jonathan Klein
Director of Music, St Gregory the Great Episcopal Church
Set a clear challenge goal and time frame
Be specific about what you’re trying to accomplish and when.
Whether it’s “Help us raise $25,000 by June 30” or “We’re unlocking a $10,000 match this Giving Tuesday,” donors need a clear goal and deadline to rally around.
Communicate urgency and deadlines in your outreach
Donors are busy (aren’t we all?).
Remind them often that time is running out! Use email, social media, and even direct mail to keep your challenge front and center. A ticking clock gets people moving.
Use motivating language like “Unlock the Match”
Make it fun!
Phrases like “Help us unlock the match” or “Double your impact today” give donors a sense of participation and teamwork. They’re not just giving—they’re helping achieve something big.
Easily run a successful matching fundraising campaign with 4aGC
At 4aGoodCause, we believe nonprofit fundraising should be simple—for you and your donors.
Our fundraising platform makes it easy to launch a matching donation challenge that drives donor engagement and raises more funds.
Ready to run your best matching gift campaign yet—one you have complete control over?
Sure you are!
Schedule a demo and see how 4aGoodCause can help you raise more (and stress less).
Ronald Pruitt
Ronald is the President and Founder of 4aGoodCause, the fundraising CRM that makes recurring, monthly giving a breeze for small nonprofits.
For over 25 years, Ronald has had the joy of doing what he loves, building online solutions that make a difference in the world. He’s helped raise millions of dollars online for small nonprofits across the country. Connect with Ronald on LinkedIn.
Grow your monthly giving program with our resources
